Rex Murphy: Who stayed in K lodge suite? Justin Trudeau’s not saying

Rex Murphy: Who stayed in $6K lodge suite? Justin Trudeau’s not saying

The prime minister has perfected the artwork of non-answers

Get the most recent from Rex Murphy straight to your inbox

Article content material

Within the historical past of human discourse it has been established, and is without end the apply, that one searching for data of one other, embodies that want within the type of what we all know as a query.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Equally venerable is the custom {that a} response to a query, its attendant and inevitable accomplice, is a solution. A query is to a solution and a solution is to a query as a bride is to a husband, a father to a son, a brother to a sister. They’re in a bonded relationship, one completes the opposite.

Article content material

Not so on the very apex of Canadian politics, that apex being the prime minister in query interval or a press convention.

Justin Trudeau sees, or offers each attainable proof of seeing, a query as an remoted pulse of sound, a purposeless cue for no matter occurs to be on what’s charmingly considered his thoughts. And as such it requires of his “reply” no sequence of logical relationship, no acquaintance or acknowledgement of what has been requested.

Commercial 3

Article content material

As a hypothetical instance an opposition member may ask him, “What time is it Prime Minister,” and Mr. Trudeau may simply come forth with the delights of vacationing on the Aga Khan’s non-public island. A extra real looking instance is perhaps if he was requested whether or not his trip on the Aga Khan’s non-public island was a breach of ethics and a battle of curiosity; he would most likely reply “4 o’clock.”

Trudeau sees … a query as an remoted pulse of sound

Or “all Canadians know that range is our energy and the carbon tax is that this authorities’s method of placing extra money into the pockets of the center class.”

It issues not how particular the query. For instance once more, this week Pierre Poilievre requested Trudeau if he was the occupant of the $6,000-a-night, butler-equipped suite on the luxurious London lodge through the Queen’s funeral. And Trudeau, with virtuoso aloofness, responded to that extremely discrete inquiry by charging that Poilievre (paraphrase) had no regard for the Constitution of Rights and Freedoms since he had not declared his horror at Doug Ford’s utilization of the however clause through the present dispute with CUPE over compensation for Ontario’s training employees.

Commercial 4

Article content material

If truth be told, “Sure” or “No” would have performed the job fairly effectively. However Trudeau’s reply genes don’t work that method. Poilievre persevered, however all that was returned by means of a solution was why he, Poilievre was senseless of the Constitution-backed (so the courts have stated) rights of “collective bargaining” and thereby the civil liberties of all Canadians.

It’s fairly a journey in logic from an inquiry a couple of lodge room in London to a labour dispute in Ontario, however nonetheless Trudeau made it. He’s the very Paganini of the non sequitur.

To the completely different matter although of this latent concern with Canadian civil liberties and respect and reverence for the Constitution; there are some things to be noticed. And the very first is: the place did this all of the sudden come from? Particularly from this prime minister?

Commercial 5

Article content material

In the course of the two entire years of COVID, civil liberties, and the Constitution that was speculated to be defending them, had been suffocated and forgotten as by no means in Canadian historical past.

Daughters couldn’t go to an ageing mom in a long-term dwelling, even when that poor mom was in her final days or hours. Wives in 50-year marriages couldn’t sit by the bedsides of departing husbands. All of us keep in mind the pathetic sight of relations sitting outdoors within the chilly and moist by a window, urgent their arms in opposition to the glass to sign their presence and affection.

Folks had been informed they may not emerge from their homes with out masks, couldn’t have household gatherings past a sure small quantity, couldn’t journey with out a bundle of government-issued papers; some man strolling a canine, alone by a park, was charged; companies had been informed to shut, or else. Canadians had been extra circumscribed than in some other time of their total historical past, intimate relationships had been trampled on, commerce suspended, individuals fired for non-vaccination, quarantines imposed, nice fines levied.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Civil liberties … had been suffocated and forgotten

It was, as I feel I stated on the time, the most important, most complete overriding of essentially the most primary civil and human rights in Canadian historical past.

And that was simply the appetizer. Then got here the heaviest sledge-hammer of all, the invocation of the Emergencies Act over a localized (Ottawa) protest. Folks had been arrested, financial institution accounts had been frozen, police got sweeping powers, property had been seized. The good Constitution of Rights and Freedoms melted and vanished underneath the dread weight of the widest grant of state energy for the reason that Warfare Measures Act.

There have been no cries throughout both COVID or the Emergencies Act in regards to the sacred Constitution, no Galahad-like defences of “unusual Canadians’” primary rights.

On the “however clause,” nicely, there’s one other vat of hypocrisy. Instantly for a authorities to name up the clause is a dread heresy of the best offence. Quebec has known as up the however clause so usually that it’s near being a behavior. It has used it to bar public-sector employees from carrying spiritual symbols and to declare itself formally unilingual — all with out a murmur from fellow Quebecer Justin Trudeau or any of his obedient cupboard. Now it’s a matter of the best outrage that Doug Ford calls it as much as enable colleges to perform after two years of shutdown.

And Pierre Poilievre is a ruthless villain for not calling Ford out.

Possibly some eager reporter within the press gallery may ask Trudeau the place he will get the nerve to pose, now, as a defender of Canadian civil rights, given his personal apply and coverage over the previous two years. I wouldn’t hope for an actual reply although. Possibly some reflections on quantum mechanics or the fun of funeral sing-a-longs within the higher U.Okay. inns.

Meantime, simply who was it summoning the butler in that fantastic $6,000-a-night suite?

Nationwide Put up

Get the most recent from Rex Murphy straight to your inbox



Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We now have enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra data and particulars on find out how to regulate your e mail settings.

Leave a Reply